Reputation Management Game Changer – Court Ruling on Sensitive Information

There has been a new ruling from Europe’s highest court on Tuesday, May 13th, regarding Google search results containing private information. The European court ruled that if information is found to be irrelevant or outdated, users have the option of asking Google to remove such links from its database. If asked, Google must amend the links to such information.

According to the judges ruling, “If, following a search made on the basis of a person’s name, the list of results displays a link to a web page which contains information on the person in question, the data subject may approach the operator directly and, where the operator does not grant his request, bring the matter before the competent authorities in order to obtain under certain conditions, the removal of that link from the list of results.”

As a result, there is now a court order which effectively regulates what Google is allowed to display on their own website.

For a summary of this article, please click here for the quick version

Reputation Management

Reputation management is a service provided by many online marketing agencies designed to enhance a company’s online reputation, and in many cases, suppress negative information displayed about a company or individual. It is the latter service offering which is most often associated with reputation management. Typically, individuals who have criminal records, or who have received negative publicity will pay to have web properties built around them and positive press to be released in order to counteract the negative impressions. This court ruling could significantly impact this service.

Rather than working with an agency to improve their online impression, an individual can now request that the owner of a web property removes the offensive content, and if they do not respond, the individual can take it directly to Google who can be court-ordered to take this down. Though this many eliminate much poor content released by web companies who try to shortcut reputation management, it also gives an easy out and significantly less consequence and deterrent for those who are engaging in poor practices.

Google’s Previous Cooperation

Although Google is upset with the ruling, calling it “disappointing,” it has in the past voluntarily acted to protect individuals in similar reputation management cases. In October of 2013, Google made a change to it’s algorithm commonly known as the “Mugshot Update” to stop high ranking websites from appearing which displayed mugshots of arrested individuals.

These mugshot websites were an extortion scheme in which the website owner would scan public records for mugshots, put them on a website optimized to rank high on page one for the individual’s name, and charge several hundred dollars to take the mugshot down. The mugshot would also appear on other sites, which would require separate payment for the same function.

Google, recognizing the moral questionability of this practice, acted on their own to stop this from happening by significantly reducing the rankings of these mugshot websites. However, being forced by courts to change their website rankings for other areas without the same moral ambiguity is not sitting well with the search engine.

Do It Yourself – Or Not

This latest ruling will now make it easier for individuals to take reputation management into their own hands. For many individuals and small businesses, this is a good thing – especially when there are invalid claims and blatantly inflammatory postings. However, we expect that for many, the process will still be difficult to manage and that web marketing agencies will begin altering their service offerings to work with Google to eliminate the negative results.

Individuals will likely greatly benefit from working with agencies, as agencies will do this many times and develop expedient systems as opposed to an individual whom has never worked with Google before and needs to figure out not only how to navigate through Google, but even how to get a hold of a live person and confidently make a case.

We predict that the reputation management market will not go away as a result of the new ruling, but will simply change and adapt.

The Ruling Only Effects Europe – For Now

Remember, this ruling has not yet come to the United States. Things will go on as normal here. However, we do expect them to change in the not-too-distant future. It is likely that multiple cases will now be brought to the courts in the United States and that they will be forced to make a ruling. It is expected (but not guaranteed) that the US will follow suit, and that we will have a similar ruling here. It is in the best interest of online marketing agencies and affected companies/individuals to start preparing now.

This Will Not Affect Everyone

Though this ruling will cause some personal information to be taken down, the question of “how much” remains. Google may take things down very quickly in fear of the courts, but we do not believe that will be the likely scenario. It will probably take time for systems to be established and for everyone to get a good handle on how much information will be taken down. Many different types of posts will likely undergo long fights while everyone tries to figure out exactly what the ruling applies to.

We believe that there are many individuals and companies who wish this case affected them, but it won’t. These are cases such as:

  • News reports of arrests – Though such content may be perceived to be inflammatory by the affected individual, they are in fact news reports written to document facts. These are certainly relevant in the time in which the events occur, but may be relevant in the distant future as well. As long as they aren’t written as a bias piece or with inflammatory intent, these should be considered news and will likely stay.
  • Review sites – Websites like Yelp, Zagat, and Healthgrades are designed to give subjective information and honest assessment of real user experience. We cannot foresee such sites as being required to only post positive reviews and think they will largely be unaffected. However, this may change sign-in and profile requirements to ensure real users are making the reviews, and it will be likely that any reviews that cannot be substantiated in some way (i.e. attached to a real person) may be subject to removal.
  • Government reports – Documents from government agencies such as the FCC and FDA regularly report on findings and rulings. These will not be eliminated, even if they have the potential to be damaging, as they are government reports and matters of public record.
  • Public records – Any documentation that is a part of public record will remain online. This may be anything from purchase prices of homes to court records.

Who Will Be Affected?

There are many people who will be affected by the ruling, and these will likely (but not exclusively) be individuals. We estimate that the search results brought before Google for removal will primarily consist of results such as:

  • A disgruntled ex writes a blog post or creates a website about how awful their ex is.
  • Fake reviews are created on a website such as to damage a competitor’s company.
  • Incorrect information is portrayed on a website and is damaging to an individual’s reputation.
  • Someone posts an embarrassing/suggestive picture of a classmate

Where to Next?

At this point, we need to wait and see. There are no guarantees that this will make it to the United States, and if there is something that is damaging to your reputation, it does need to be taken care of immediately. If it does seem to be an insurmountable task, there could be hope on the horizon. For agencies, removal of information may be easier than you think. Please feel free to contact us if you’re having an issue. We can go over it with you and advise you of the actual difficulty and best plan of attack.

TL;DR (Too Long; Didn’t Read):

  • Europe’s highest court ruled Tuesday that Google would have to take down some sensitive information from their search results if requested.
  • Google is unhappy with the ruling, though it has voluntarily removed derogatory and extortion based posts in the past.
  • For now, this ruling will only affect Europe.
  • Many individuals may be able to perform reputation management themselves, though it may be beneficial to work with an agency.
  • This will likely affect personal attacks and posts of information (i.e. posts by jealous ex, fake inflammatory posts, etc.).
  • Review sites (i.e. Yelp, Healthgrades, etc.) are likely to be minimally affected.
  • Documentation of fact (i.e. news reports, government documentation, etc.) will likely not be affected.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Our Partners

facebook marketing partner
google partner
shopify logo
hubspot partner program

European Office

Agentur Webfox

Berlin, Germany

Join Our Newsletter!

@ 2023 Points Group / All Rights Reserved

Privacy Policy

This Privacy Policy governs the manner in which Points Group, LLC collects, uses, maintains and discloses information collected from users (each, a “User”) of the website (“Site”). This privacy policy applies to the Site and all products and services offered by Points Group, LLC.


We may collect personal identification information from Users in a variety of ways, including, but not limited to, when Users visit our site, subscribe to the newsletter, respond to a survey, fill out a form, and in connection with other activities, services, features or resources we make available on our Site. Users may visit our Site anonymously. We will collect personal identification information from Users only if they voluntarily submit such information to us. Users can always refuse to supply personal identification information, except that it may prevent them from engaging in certain Site related activities.


We may collect non-personal identification information about Users whenever they interact with our Site. Non-personal identification information may include the browser name, the type of computer and technical information about User’s means of connection to our Site, such as the operating system and the Internet service providers utilized and other similar information.


Our Site may use “cookies” to enhance User experience. User’s web browser places cookies on their hard drive for record-keeping purposes and sometimes to track information about them. User may choose to set their web browser to refuse cookies, or to alert them when cookies are being sent. If they do so, note that some parts of the Site may not function properly.


Points Group, LLC may collect and use Users personal information for the following purposes:

  • To improve customer service
  • Information you provide helps us respond to your customer service requests and support needs more efficiently.
  • To personalize user experience
  • We may use information in the aggregate to understand how our Users as a group use the services and resources provided on our Site.
  • To improve our Site
  • We may use feedback you provide to improve our products and services.
  • To run a promotion, contest, survey or other Site feature
  • To send Users information they agreed to receive about topics we think will be of interest to them.
  • To send periodic emails
  • We may use the email address to respond to their inquiries, questions, and/or other requests. If User decides to opt-in to our mailing list, they will receive emails that may include company news, updates, related product or service information, etc. If at any time the User would like to unsubscribe from receiving future emails, we include detailed unsubscribe instructions at the bottom of each email.


We adopt appropriate data collection, storage and processing practices and security measures to protect against unauthorized access, alteration, disclosure or destruction of your personal information, username, password, transaction information and data stored on our Site.


We do not sell, trade, or rent User’s personal identification information to others. We may share generic aggregated demographic information not linked to any personal identification information regarding visitors and users with our business partners, trusted affiliates and advertisers for the purposes outlined above. We may use third party service providers to help us operate our business and the Site or administer activities on our behalf, such as sending out newsletters or surveys. We may share your information with these third parties for those limited purposes provided that you have given us your permission.


Users may find advertising or other content on our Site that link to the sites and services of our partners, suppliers, advertisers, sponsors, licensors and other third parties. We do not control the content or links that appear on these sites and are not responsible for the practices employed by websites linked to or from our Site. In addition, these sites or services, including their content and links, may be constantly changing. These sites and services may have their own privacy policies and customer service policies. Browsing and interaction on any other website, including websites which have a link to our Site, is subject to that website’s own terms and policies.


Points Group, LLC has the discretion to update this privacy policy at any time. When we do, we will revise the updated date at the bottom of this page. We encourage Users to frequently check this page for any changes to stay informed about how we are helping to protect the personal information we collect. You acknowledge and agree that it is your responsibility to review this privacy policy periodically and become aware of modifications.


By using this Site, you signify your acceptance of this policy. If you do not agree to this policy, please do not use our Site. Your continued use of the Site following the posting of changes to this policy will be deemed your acceptance of those changes.


If you have any questions about this Privacy Policy, the practices of this site, or your dealings with this site, please contact us at:

Points Group, LLC

150 Morristown Road, Suite 220

Bernardsville, NJ 07924

This document was last updated on July 24, 2014